After two LEM Round Tables on the subject (Steve Jobs' Legacy at
Apple and My
Favorite Mac Mouse), I figure I'll continue to beat the dead horse
that is the puck mouse controversy with some insight I've found while
using my puck mouse.
You're Holding It Wrong
Manufactured long
before the iPhone 4 and Antennagate, the puck mouse suffers from a case
of "you're holding it wrong." Most people say it's supposed to be
intuitive to use a mouse, and I agree - but claiming that Apple has
always made intuitive mice is a bit of a stretch, don't you think?
After all, there were the wonderfully-informative ads for the original
Mac mouse that demonstrated how to properly hold the mouse - in an
actual "pointing" gesture.
Yeah, how well did that work?
At any rate, I at
least found the puck mouse to be quite intuitive. Maybe it's my years
of playing the piano, but my fingers seemed to know instantly how to
hold it: thumb on the left colored area, pinky and ring finger on the
right colored area, index and middle finger on the button. My palm
never touched the mouse, and my hand seemed to float above it. It's
quite comfortable to use that way (maybe my arms and wrists are
strengthened from playing the piano), and I've had no problems with
holding it sideways, even in the dark.
My parents even
liked the puck, especially my dad, which makes me wonder if it's
something genetic.
Surprise, Surprise
In light of my love for the puck mouse, I'll let you in on
something: Before I tried it, I had been bashing it. Yes, I'd read all
the comments about the horrendousness of the puck mouse, and to my
great surprise, my artificial disgust with the puck faded away the
moment I put it in my hand. It was quite a shock to me, really - here,
I'd been reading all about how horrible the puck mouse was, how it was
one of the worst designs Apple had ever made, and yet, as I started
moving it around for the first time, my only thought was, "This is so
cool!"
Not coincidentally, I think it was the puck mouse that made me
reconsider my dislike of CRTs as well - every CRT I'd used up to this
point had been either washed out, unsaturated, grainy, or filled with
field lines. My blueberry iMac's
CRT is amazingly clear and crisp, and the fast refresh rate does
wonders for my poor eyes.
Conclusion
I encourage all those who have hated the puck mouse to give it
another try (and possibly take up the piano!). Try different hand
positions, try using your non-dominant hand, try using it at different
heights or at different lengths away from your body. It's a delightful
little mouse to use, and one that has earned itself, in my humble
opinion, an unfairly poor reputation.
Austin Leeds is a Mac and iPad user - and a college student in Iowa.