The 65
watt power adapter that came with my 17" PowerBook looks nice,
and it works fine, but it always seems a bit fragile and "delicate" for
serious road work, what with its removable plugin modular long cord or
short flip-out prong AC connector - stuff that can go adrift and too
easily get lost - at least if you're absent-minded like me. A notebook
power adapter used on the road leads a rough life, so it's nice if its
components are all permanently connected - and above all other
qualities it needs to be rugged.
Happily, FastMac has a solution - the TruePower AC Adapter is built
for the road well traveled. The TruePower adapter is designed to be
tough, with solid and fixed cord connections, sturdy cords, and a
rugged housing. It provides 12 feet of extension between your 'Book and
the power socket.
It's not as pretty as the Apple adapter, but it's an inexpensive,
heavy duty alternative to the latter with no removable components, and
it's built so robustly that it looks like you could throw it under a
truck and not worry about damage.
Oh, wait; FastMac actually did throw one under a truck. Read on for
more about that.
If you're a serious user of notebook computers, sooner or later
you're likely be shopping for a replacement AC power adapter, either
because the original one that came with your 'Book has failed, been
damaged, or gotten lost - or simply because you've determined that it's
a smart idea to have a spare.
You could just buy a second Apple adapter to replace the original or
to carry as a spare, at least if your 'Book is a 400 MHz TiBook or iBook or
newer (Apple no longer lists replacement adapters for older
'Books).
Or you can save some money and go with a third-party adapter -
the tough FastMac TruePower unit being a logical candidate. The
TruePower unit supplies 65 watts, which is plenty to support a 17"
PowerBook G4 like mine. It's offered in two models - one that works
with most older PowerPC 'Books (except for the PowerBook 5300), including the PowerBook 1400 through the Pismo PowerBook G3 and Clamshell iBooks. The companion model
supports the metal PowerBooks and white iBooks. (At this point, nobody
is licensed to make a replacement adapter using Apple's proprietary
MagSafe connection.)
AC power adapters for notebooks have never been one of Apple's
strongest points, although Apple is pitching the magnetic-attachment
MagSafe adapter that ships with its Intel-powered notebooks as a major
feature. It's hard to fault the functional objective of MagSafe, which
is designed to disengage from the computer under sudden shock loads,
such as someone tripping over the power cable, thus preempting possible
serious damage to the notebook.
One off my offspring once tripped on the Lombard PowerBook's adapter cord,
launching the unfortunate laptop off the chair it had been perched on
to land on the floor across the room. Amazingly, while the coaxial plug
that connected the power cord to the computer was mangled beyond
repair, the Lombard itself sustained no noticeable damage and remained
in fine fettle through three subsequent owners that we know of over
several years until we lost track of it. Still, that's the sort of
thing you would rather avoid, so the MagSafe gets a qualified
thumbs-up.
One downside so far is that there are so far no less-expensive
third-party alternatives to the Apple-branded MagSafe units, presumably
because the technology is patented and Apple wants a stiff price for
licensing, if willing to granted it at all. But I digress.
Conventional power adapter technology used with PowerPC PowerBooks
and iBooks is not protected by exclusive patents, so there is a variety
of other-branded adapters that can be used with these older
machines.
Apple's own notebook power adapters in the PowerPC era have had a
spotty reputation. The adapter that shipped with the PowerBook 5300 was
relatively big and clunky, but robust enough. It was the motherboard
socket that the audio jack-like DC connector plugged into that gave
trouble, having a baneful tendency to come unsoldered.
The PowerBooks 1400, 3400,
3500, and 2400 used basically the same adapter
unit as the 5300, but with a stronger and better-designed "barrel ring"
coaxial plug that remained standard until the introduction of the
Titanium PowerBook in 2001.
The PowerBook G3
Series WallStreet and Lombard power adapters were recalled in 1999
with reference to a potential fire hazard and replaced with the oddball
"flying saucer" or "yo-yo" AC adapter that shipped with the original
Clamshell iBook and PowerBook G3 2000 Pismo. The purported functional
advantage of the disc-shaped adapter was that its yo-yo configured
housing formed a reel upon which you could coil the DC cord, but the
thing was bulky to stow and carry, strange-looking, and not especially
rugged, with cord failures and sometimes consequent electrical arcing a
fairly common complaint. Some of us wondered if Apple had recalled the
wrong adapter.
I still have a couple of the recalled G3 PowerBook adapters,
and they have been in pretty much constant service for nearly a decade
years with no fires yet or any evident heat issues. That is not a
recommendation, however, and my advice is to follow Apple's and replace
these questionable adapters. The FastMac TruePower adapter would be an
excellent and affordable replacement.
The square white AC adapters that shipped with the metal PowerBooks
and white iBooks are arguably the best of the pre-MagSafe lot - at
least I've encountered no problems with them. They use a smaller
connector barrel-ring plug than the G3 PowerBook and flying saucer
adapters, so they are not interchangeable with the latter, although
they would otherwise be compatible. However, with their flip-out AC
plug prongs and relatively small diameter DC connector cords, they are
not the most robust units, and they have a reputation for premature
failure.
Apple has posted a Knowledge Base
tutorial on troubleshooting of these power adapters, particularly
addressing the following issues:
- Your power adapter won't charge the computer.
- The LEDs in the adapter don't light when the adapter is
connected.
- The adapter only charges the computer intermittently.
I mentioned in the preamble to this review that the
FastMac TruePower adapter is a rugged little unit.
How rugged? Well, FastMac drop-kicked one of the TruePower adapters
several times, then ran over it repeatedly with a minivan, as the
pictures illustrate.
"Our TruePower AC adapter is not only smaller than most third-party
replacements, it's more durable. It can be dropped, kicked, and even
run over by a truck and still work," says Michael Lowdermilk, Business
Development Manager for FastMac. "We know because we did it and have
the video to prove
it."
As with the old Timex watch torture-test TV commercials,the scuffed
but still intact TruePower adapter worked just fine after its
ordeal.
The cool thing is that you can buy two of these adapters - one for
your desktop workstation and another for your computer bag, for less
than the price of one Apple-brand adapter.
The
TruePower adapter provides constant wattage output that meets or
exceeds Apple-Branded adapters.
One thing you will miss with this adapter is the Apple OEM unit's
colored status LEDs, located in the head of the DC Barrel ring
connector that plugs into the computer indicating charging status. an
amber ring showing while the battery is charging, and a green ring
indicating a full charge. However, the FastMac adapter does have a
power on LED.
The FastMac adapter isn't as swish and stylish-looking as the Apple
adapter, but while FastMac pitches it as "not pretty," it's presentably
attractive in white, with matching white cables of generous diameter
and 10 feet of extension length which look and feel very robust. Its
simple, no-frills design minimizes vulnerability to damage. I've always
been impressed with the quality of FastMac products, and this one is no
exception.
Apple notebook models officially supported by the white $39.95
FastMac APP-6265 power adapter include:
- Clamshell iBook
- 12" & 14" iBook G3
- 12" & 14" iBook G4
- PowerBook G3
- Titanium PowerBook G4
- 12", 15", & 17" Aluminum PowerBook G4
Apple notebook models officially supported by the black $35.95
FastMac APP-5553 power adapter include:
- Clamshell iBook
- 12" & 14" iBook G3
- 12" & 14" iBook G4
- PowerBook G3
- Titanium PowerBook G4
- 12", 15", & 17" Aluminum PowerBook G4
And as noted above, there is no reason why the APP-5553 adapter
can't be used with a PowerBook 1400, 3400, or 2400.
I've been using one of these FastMac TruePower AC adapters with my
PowerBook for about a year and a half. I haven't run over it with any
automobiles or drop-kicked it, but it's been completely trouble-free,
puts out plenty of power, and runs cooler than the Apple adapter.
Features
- TruePower AC Adapter available for all iBooks & G3/G4
PowerBooks
- 65 Watts, dual voltage (100-240 volts). 10-foot reach. 1-Year
Warranty.
- Compact Design, Extremely Portable
Specifications
- Input: AC 100-240V
- Output: DC 24V, 2.7A, 65W
- Fuse rating: 2.5A/250V
- Dimensions: 1.1" x 2 "x 4.3" (29mm x 51mm x 109mm)
- Length: 10 feet
The TruePower adapter is covered by a 1-year warranty and a 30-day
money back guarantee.
There is also a FastMac TruePower Auto/Air Power Adapter
(for the later model, small-plug machines only) that sells for $10 more
if you need to be able to charge from mobile power sources.
